While the classic (and most typical) color for a Shaligram is black, various Puranic and Tantric texts describe Shaligrams as being black, red, yellow (honey-colored), white/whitish, sky-colored/blue, or brown. The Pranatoshini Tantra, a 565-page encyclopedic compilation of earlier scriptural texts composed in Bengal in the 19th century, is another one of the most commonly referenced scriptural authorities on Shaligram identification. It quotes an additional writing called the Yogaparijata that describes any Shaligram with a white color (or displaying â€œwhite teeth marksâ€) as particularly inclined to bring good fortune to the devotee. As a result, any given Shaligram or group of Shaligrams might contain a combination of colors, from the overall color of the standard black shale nodule to white quartz bands, reddish or golden iron pyrites, or green calcite.
Color is sometimes a confusing topic, however. The Skanda Purana (also in Pranatoshini Tantra, page 347), for example, references twenty categorical divisions of Shaligrams based on mixed variations of color and texture: (1) Glaced (meaning polished), (2) Black, (3) Brown, (4) Yellow, (5) Blue, (6) Red, (7) Rough, (8) Curved, (9) Big, (10) Unmarked, (11) Reddish brown, (12) Variegated, (13) Broken, (14) With many circular marks (chakras), (15) With a single circular mark, (16) With a long opening, (17) With a big circular mark, (18) Having two or more circular marks joined with each other, (19) Having a broken circular mark, and (20) Having an opening at the base.[i] The Skanda Purana then goes on to explain the likely results of worshipping each of the color-type varieties:[ii]
A color-type and size list compiled by a Sri Vaishnava ritual specialist, however, includes another wide variety of possible combinations:
Furthermore, according to the Yogaparijata, the veneration of broken, unusually large, or rough Shaligrams can cause the loss of wealth, of intellect, and of lifetime longevity respectively. And if that wasnâ€™t enough, the Pranatoshini Tantra [iv] describes even more results of worship based on the number of circular marks (chakras) along the surface of a Shaligram (a characteristic I will address in a later post about chakras). The Prayogaparaijata section, however, describes the results of worshipping different colors of Shaligrams that contain only a single circular mark (second section), all of which relate to the expected behavior of the Shaligram once it returns home with a devotee (Prayogaparaijata quoted in Pranatoshini Tantra, page 361):
The scriptures therefore tend to advise that only the first five color-types of Shaligram recorded in the Skanda Purana should ever be worshipped by devotees. This means that, in practice, most practitioners only keep Shaligrams that are black, brown, yellow/honey-colored, or blue/sky-colored (or that have a combination of those colors).
Shaligrams that appear in other colors should then either be turned over for temple care or simply avoided entirely. In general though, the Puranic texts remain primarily concerned with the quality of Shaligrams as far as they might be considered ritually viable rather than their color specifically. For example, most of the scriptures also contain injunctions against worshipping Shaligrams that have been cracked (by accident, use, or by intention). Shaligrams that are broken into pieces, have holes that continue all the way through the shila, Shaligrams that have been burnt by fire, Shaligrams that have been stolen by an insane person or an enemy, or those that have lost their circular marks because of long-term handling are also all considered to be unfit for ritual practice in most circumstances. The reasons given for this is that the deity is likely to abandon a worn or defective body in the same way that a person discards old clothes or, in some cases, the way the elderly give up their worn and used up bodies in death (dehe jirune yathaa dehi tyktvaanyamupagacchati lingaadini tu jirnaani tathaa munchati devataa – quoted in Pranatoshiá¹‡i Tantra, page 361.)
In practice, red Shaligrams are typically of the greatest concern and were described, more than once, as the most inauspicious form a Shaligram could take and that these were not worshipped due to the trouble they tended to bring. On the rare occasion that a red Shaligram was found, most devotees either immediately returned it to the river or packed it securely in cloth for transport to a temple where, as several explained, it would be looked after by a temple priest (pujari or brahmacharya) so that its unusual potency would not inadvertently cause problems for devotees elsewhere. In other cases, devotees pointed out that such Shaligrams were mostly associated with destruction and death and therefore, should only be worshipped by especially knowledgeable and skilled practitioners. When I asked if this was why the red-orange â€œmountainâ€ Shaligrams (those not yet worn by the river) were also similarly shunned, many devotees responded affirmatively. Their formations were pure but their colors were a warning.
The concern about red coloration, however, is not extended to one particular formation of Shaligrams called Ratnagarbha, a small, translucent, pebble-like shila that, when held up to a bright light source, turns bright red, yellow, or occasionally blue (it appears black otherwise).
Overall, different colors of Shaligrams are associated with different ritual effects. The standard black Shaligrams are sometimes said to bestow fame or general good fortune while brown Shaligrams are thought to remove sins committed in previous lives. Yellow Shaligrams are also occasionally described as particularly beneficial to children and blue (or â€œsky-coloredâ€) Shaligrams as bringers of wealth and prosperity. These color categories, however, though mentioned in the Puranic texts, are quite complex in practice and there are debates among devotees as to what constitutes which color category (i.e., the difference between a brown Shaligram and a yellow one) and what those colors mean. In the end though, as far as most practitioners are concerned, you can never go wrong with black.
[i] See also Rabindra Kumar Siddhantashastree. 1985. Vaishnavism Through the Ages. pages 27-49
[ii] Interestingly, this text also describes the characteristics of reading Dwarka shilas, which are also divided into a number of different varieties according to their colors and outward appearances (Padma Purana, quoted in Pranatoshini Tantra, page 360.)
(1) The blue type: It is the giver of untimely death
(2) The reddish brown: It brings in serious dangers.
(3) Variegated: It gives insanity
(4) Yellow: It causes destruction of wealth.
(5) Smoky Color: It causes untimely death of children.
(6) The broken type: It causes death of wife.
(7) The white type with dot prints: It fulfils all desires.
(8) The type with unbroken circular marks: It removes poverty and sorrow.
(9) The type having glaced circular shape: It gives the same results as above.
(10) The type with quadrangular shape: It gives the same result as above.
(11) The type with even number of circular marks: It gives bliss and worldly pleasure.
(12) The type with odd number of circular marks: It causes sorrow and worldly pain.
The same authority adds that one should not offer worship to any of the following types because of their habit of giving undesirable results
(1) The type with one or more holes on its body.
(2) The broken one.
(3) That which is neither round, nor has angles on its sides.
(4) That which has odd number of circles marked on its body.
(5) That which is shaped like the half part of the moon.
[iii] Balasubramanian, Venkatesh. 2003. Sri Ranga Sri â€œThe Story of Shaligram.â€ Ibiblio Archives. http://www.ibiblio.org/sripedia/srirangasri/archives/dec03/msg00007.html. Accessed 2 Dec 2016).
[iv] The Pranatoshini Tantra is one of the two largest and most comprehensive scriptural compendia of tantric practices from northeast India, along with the 16th century BrÍŽhat Tantrasara. See: Hugh B. Urban. 2009. The Power of Tantra: Religion, Sexuality and the Politics of South Asian Studies. I. B. Tauris Publishers.
Pranatoshini Tantra. à¤ªà¥à¤°à¤¾à¤£à¤¤à¥‹à¤·à¤¿à¤£à¥€. 1983. Ramatoá¹£aá¹‡a Bhaá¹á¹a and Ramadatta Shukla, trans. Prayaga: Shakta Sadhana Piá¹ha Publishers.
Thank you for the blog on colour of salagrams. I have a flat round salagram, reddish in colour – with the chakra open. Would that make it inauspicious?
Not necessarily. It’s hard to know without seeing it, but in most cases the Shaligram in question is actually brown and not red, or it is black with red markings. Either of which is fine. — HW
It is reddish brown as opposed to yellowish brown. Plus there is a blackish patch. In the section on colour – the dangers of red salagrams appears alarming. Would you suggest I donate it to a temple instead?
If you are concerned that it may, in fact, be a red Shaligram, that is the usual advice. Most red Shaligrams go to temple care or they are given to sannyasis. But in the end, it’s up to you and what you feel is the right choice. — HW
Thank you – have handed over to temple.
Thank you for providing excellent information.
Why black colour of Shaligram shila is fading?
is their any possibility that outer crust of black could be removed and reddish surface would appear?
Why black colour of Shaligram shila is fading?Is their any possibility that outer crust of black could be removed and reddish surface would appear?
That would be highly unusual. This is only a short comment but my concern is that the Shaligram in question might have been painted and that is what is fading or chipping off. Black Shaligrams can appear greyish or even blue when they are dry but they do not fade, generally speaking. — HW
Sri Gurubhyo Namaha.
Dear Sir, I am a Madhwa brahmin and I am from Bangalore, Karnataka. I have 80+ Shaligramas at home and there are couple of shaligramas are brown in colour, however I am not sure whether it is reddish brown or normal brown. Will you be able to help me by giving your e-mail address/WhaptsApp phone number of yours, so that I can share the videos/phones of those shaligramas. If you think some of those shaligramas should not be kept at home then I will give it in the Uttaradi mutt. It would be great if I get to show all those shaligramas to you as we don’t get people like you who has great knowledge about shaligramas. Please help me sir. I also noticed from the time I bought these shaligramas I don’t have peace, financial crisis and also quarrels at home. It might be a coincidence, hence please help me sir. Eagerly waiting for your reply.
Yes, I can help. If you have good quality photos of the shilas you are concerned about, send them to prolegomenon(at)gmail.com. I will tell you what I can. — HW
Thank you so much for considering my request sir
I don’t have all photos, however i also have lot of videos of the Shaligramas that i have. If you can let me know the site through which I can upload the videos or your WhatsApp number only for sharing the Shaligrama videos sir please
Please let me know sir
Sure. My WhatsApp is 1 781 330 3121. That should get the images to me in the easiest way. — HW
Thank you so much for your kindness and support Sir
Will share rightaway
I live in the US and i just realized what i have is a Shaligram which my mother gave me without much information on it. On my visit to India she gave it to me and told me to keep it in my home mandir. One day i stumbled upon some videos of Shaligram which made me realize that maybe what I have is a Shaligram. I needed some knowledgeable help to guide me understand if it really is a Shaligram and what kind. While doing some internet research i found your website which has so much information on it. I would like to share a picture with you.I was hoping you can tell me more about it. Awaiting your reply. Please let me know where i could share the picture. Thank you, Many rergards.
Hi Meena! I will certainly try to tell you what I can. The best way to do this virtually is if you can send me a few good quality photos of the shila that show all sides of it. You can then email me the photos at prolegomenon (at) gmail (dot) com. If you have any additional information about where it came from in India, that would be helpful. — HW
yes i can do that. Thank you!Confirming the email address once again
Yes, that appears correct — HW
I have emailed you pictures of my Shila. Please let me know if you recieved my email. Thank you very much for your help.